|
Antonio
Cao, * Renzo Galanello, M. Cristina Rosatelli
Clinica e Biologia dell'Et� Evolutiva, Universita Studi
Cagliari, Cagliari, Sardinia, Italy
Address: *Ist. Clinica e Biologia dell'Eta Evolutiva, Universit�
Studi Cagliari,
Via Jenner s/n, 09121 Cagliari, Sardinia, Italy
Tel. 0039-070-503341
Fax 0039-070-503696
Email: acao@mcweb.unica.it
Download as a
PDF here
SUMMARY
The most important aspects of carrier detection procedures,
genetic counselling, population screening and fetal diagnosis of
the thalassaemias and sickle cell anaemia are reviewed. Carrier
detection can be made retrospectively, i.e. following the birth of
an affected child, or prospectively. Most carrier detection and
genetic counselling in populations at risk for a-thalassaemia and
sickle cell anaemia is retrospective. However, some prospective
carrier screening programmes for sickle cell anaemia are ongoing in
Cuba and Guadeloupe and very limited screening for a-thalassaemia
is in progress in some South East Asian populations. As regards
b-thalassaemia, several programmes, based on carrier screening and
counselling of couples at marriage, preconception, or early
pregnancy, have been operating with several populations at risk in
the Mediterranean. These programmes have been very effective, as is
proved by the fact that he target population has improved its
knowledge of thalassaemia and its prevention, and by the marked
decline that has been observed in the incidence of thalassaemia
major. Carrier detection is carried out by haematological methods,
followed by mutation detection by DNA analysis. Prenatal diagnosis
is accomplished by mutation analysis on PCR-amplified DNA from
chorionic villi. Future prospects include automation of the process
of mutation detection, simplification of preconception and
preimplantation diagnosis, and fetal diagnosis by analysis of fetal
cells in the maternal circulation.
Key words: b-thalassaemia; a-thalassaemia, sickle cell anaemia;
carrier detection, population screening, prenatal diagnosis
INTRODUCTION
The inherited haemoglobinopathies are large groups of autosomal
recessive disorders that include the thalassaemias and sickle cell
anaemia. The thalassaemias are caused by the defective (+) or
absent (0) production of one of the globin chains of the
haemoglobin tetramer. According to the type of globin chain
involved, we distinguish a-, b- and d-thalassaemias (Weatherall and
Clegg, 1981). The sickle disorders most commonly result from
homozygosity for the S mutation, an A�T substitution at codon 6 of
the b-globin gene leading to the replacement of valine for glutamic
acid.
The incidence of b-thalassaemias is high in the Mediterranean
area, the Middle East, the Indian Subcontinent, and the Far East.
The frequency of the a-thalassaemias is particularly high in the
Far East, but the condition is not rare in the Mediterranean area,
the Middle East, and the Indian Subcontinent. Sickle cell anaemia
shows the highest incidence in tropical Africa. However, due to the
population flow and the slave trade, these diseases have spread
widely nowadays and occur also with relatively high frequency in
northern Europe, North and South America, and in the Caribbean. The
best available approximate estimate indicates that about 250
million people, 4.5% of the world population, are carriers of a
defective globin gene. Each year about 300,000 affected homozygotes
are born, approximately equally divided between sickle cell
disorders and thalassaemia syndromes (WHO Scientific Group,
1996).
At present a limited proportion of affected homozygotes may be
cured definitively by bone marrow transplantation from human
leukocyte antigen (HLA) identical siblings. However, the majority
of patients can only count on supportive management at present.
We herein review carrier detection and fetal diagnosis of
inherited haemoglobinopathies, which are fundamental issues in the
clinical management of these disorders nowadays.
CARRIER DETECTION
Heterozygous b-thalassaemia, both the � and the b+ type, is
characterised by a high red blood cell count, microcytosis,
hypochromia, increased haemoglobin A2 (HbA2) levels, and an
unbalanced a-globin non-a-globin chain synthesis. However, several
environmental or genetic factors may modify this haematological
phenotype, causing carrier identification difficulties (Table 1).
Although iron deficiency may decrease the typical high
HbA2 levels of heterozygous b-thalassaemia, in our
experience they remain within the b-thalassaemia carrier range
except in the case of severe anaemia (Galanello et al, 1981). At
any rate, iron studies may serve to rule out associated iron
deficiency.
In many carrier detection procedures, the preliminary selection
of individuals at risk of being heterozygous for a form of
thalassaemia is based on the determination of mean corpuscular
volume (MCV) and mean corpuscular haemoglobin (MCH) values. It is
worth noting, however, that since double heterozygotes for
b-thalassaemia and a-thalassaemia may have normal MCV and MCH
values, they could be missed by this approach (Melis et al, 1983;
Rosatelli et al, 1984). In carriers of b�-thalassaemia, the
a-thalassaemia determinants that can give this effect are deletion
of two of the four a2-globin structural genes and
presence of non-deletion mutations affecting the major
a2-globin gene.
Elevation of HbA2 is the most important feature in
the identification of heterozygous b-thalassaemia (Weatherall and
Clegg, 1981). Nevertheless, a number of heterozygotes for
b-thalassaemia may have normal or borderline HbA2 levels
(Galanello et al, 1994) (Table 2). The first groups of these atypical
carriers are heterozygotes for a few mild b+-thalassaemia
mutations, i.e. mutations associated with a consistent residual
output of b-globin chains from the affected b locus. A typical
example in this category is the case of heterozygotes for the b+
IVS I nt 6 T�C mutation. A normal HbA2 level is also a
characteristic feature of the b- and d-thalassaemia double
heterozygotes, who still maintain low MCV and MCH values. These
double heterozygotes should be differentiated from the
a-thalassaemia carrier by globin chain synthesis analysis and/or
gene analysis. d-globin gene analysis may be carried out by the
same methods described for b-thalassaemia, using complementary
primers or probes to the prevalent d-globin gene mutation in each
population at risk. gdb- and db-thalassaemias also have normal
HbA2. However, db-thalassaemia is easily defined by the
presence of thalassaemia-like haematological features and by a
marked increase in HbF, which is heterogeneously distributed.
Another major problem in carrier screening is the identification
of silent b-thalassaemia and the triple a-globin gene arrangement,
both of which may lead to intermediate forms of thalassaemia by
interaction with typical heterozygous b-thalassaemia. Silent
b-thalassaemias are characterised by normal MCV and MCH values and
normal HbA2 and HbF, and are defined only by a slight
imbalance in the a-globin/non a-globin synthesis (Gonzales-Redondo
et al, 1989; Galanello et al, 1994). However, on examining the
haematological features of these carriers, it should at times be
possible to find some borderline HbA2 or MCV and MCH
values, which may signal the presence of atypical b-thalassaemia,
thus calling for further studies. The most common silent
b-thalassaemia is the b+ -101 G�T mutation, the other types being
very rare (Gonzales-Redondo et al, 1989). Nevertheless, according
to globin chain synthesis analysis, the phenotype resulting from
the triple a-globin gene arrangement is at times completely silent.
It is worth noting, however, that compound heterozygotes for silent
or typical b-thalassaemia and double heterozygotes for typical
b-thalassaemia and the triple a-globin gene arrangement result in
attenuated forms of thalassaemia (Galanello et al, 1983; Thein et
al, 1984; Kulozik et al, 1987).
An extreme though rare instance of the thalassaemia gene
combination that may result in pitfalls of carrier diagnosis is the
presence of a-, d- and b-thalassaemias together. This case may lead
to a completely silent phenotype (Galanello et al, 1988).
The sickle cell trait is easily identified by haemoglobin
electrophoresis or high-pressure liquid chromatography (HPLC). The
phenotype of the sickle cell trait may be modified by co-inherited
a-thalassaemia, which leads to reduced HbS levels in varying
degrees, depending on the number of affected a-globin genes.
However, this does not lead to carrier identification problems
(Higgs et al., 1982). Based on this analysis of carrier
identification, we suggest to follow the flow chart outlined in Figure
1 (Cao and Rosatelli, 1993).
The first group of tests includes MCV and MCH determination and
haemoglobin chromatography by HPLC. HPLC may lead to the detection
of the most common, clinically relevant haemoglobin variants, such
as HbS, HbC, HbD Punjab, HbO Arab and HbE, all of which may result
in a sickle disorder in homozygosity or compound
heterozygosity.
HPLC may also be used to quantitate HbA2 and HbF
(Galanello et al, 1995). It should be noted that HPLC can also
detect Hb Knossos, a mild b-thalassaemia allele, which is not
defined by commonly used electrophoretic procedures in haemoglobin
analysis. With this flow chart, the only cases that could be missed
are the silent b-thalassaemia and the triple a-globin gene
arrangement. In the presence of low MCH and MCV levels and high
HbA2 levels, a diagnosis of heterozygous b-thalassaemia
is made. A phenotype characterised by microcytosis, hypochromia,
normal-borderline HbA2 and normal HbF may result from
iron deficiency, a-thalassaemia, gdb- thalassaemia,
b+d-thalassaemia or mild b-thalassaemia. After excluding iron
deficiency by erythrocyte ZnPP determination and evaluation of
transferrin saturation, the different thalassaemia determinants
leading to this phenotype are discriminated by globin chain
synthesis analysis and eventually by a-, d- and b-globin gene
analysis. In the presence of normal MCV and borderline
HbA2 levels, we suspect the presence of a silent
mutation (for instance b+ -101 C�T, b+ -92 C, or b+ IVS II nt 844
CCG) or the triple -globin gene arrangement, and proceed directly
to a- and b-globin gene analysis, since in many of these cases the
a/b ratio could be normal. Definition of the type of thalassaemia
in these carriers is recommended only in the event of mating with a
person with a typical, high HbA2-b-thalassaemia, or with
a carrier of an undetermined type of thalassaemia. In those rare
cases that show normal or low MCH and MCV, normal or reduced
HbA2 levels and high HbF, we suspect the presence of
db-thalassaemia, which should be differentiated from HPFH. We
distinguish between b-thalassaemia and HPFH by analysing the red
blood cell distribution of HbF, which is heterogeneous in
db-thalassaemia and homogeneous in HPFH, by globin chain synthesis
analysis (normal in HPFH and unbalanced in db-thalassaemia) and/or
b cluster gene analysis.
In populations with a relatively low incidence of both b- and
a-thalassaemia, screening by MCV and MCH or osmotic fragility could
be acceptable, because in this condition the number of false
negatives resulting from double heterozygosity for a- and
b-thalassaemia may be very low.
MOLECULAR
DIAGNOSIS
In couples at risk, identified by the above carrier detection
procedure, the specific mutation is defined using one of the
several polymerase chain reaction (PCR) based methods.
b-Thalassemia
b -Thalassemia is very heterozygous at the molecular level. To
date, at least 150 different molecular defects have defined
(Huisman and Carver, 1998). The majority of mutations affecting the
b -globin gene are point mutations or oligonucleotide additions or
deletions. Very rarely b -thalassemia results from the globin gene
deletion mechanism. In spite of this marked heterogenity a limited
number of molecular defects are prevalent in every population at
risk (Table 3). This may be very useful in practice,
because the most appropriate probes or primes can be selected
according to the carrier's ethnic origin. Mutation detection is
carried out on PCR-amplified-b -globin genes. The most commonly
used screening procedures for known mutations today are reverse
oligonucleotide hybridisation (RDB) with oligonucleotide probes or
primer specific amplification (ARMS).
Reverse dot-blot
hybridisation (RDB)
Reverse dot-blot hybridisation uses membrane-bound
allele-specific oligonucleotide probes that hybridise to the
complementary sequence of the PCR product prepared using patient
DNA as the starting template (SAIKI et al, 1989) (
Figure 2). In this format, multiple pairs of normal and mutant
allele-specific oligonucleotides can be placed on a small strip of
membrane. Hybridisation with PCR-amplified b -globin gene DNA will
detect any of the mutations screened in a single procedure. Up to
20-30 mutations have indeed been screened in one single step.
Primer-specific
amplification (ARMS)
With this method, the target DNA fragment is amplified using a
common primer and either of two primers: a primer complementary to
the mutation to be detected (b -thalassemia primer), or a primer
complementary to the normal DNA at the same position (normal
primer). Another b -globin gene fragment is simultaneously
co-amplified to control the amplification step of the procedure
(Newton et al, 1989). Normal DNA is amplified only by the normal
primer DNA from homozygotes only by the b -thalassemia primer and
DNA from heterozygotes by both primers.
Other known
mutation-detection procedures
Other methodologies which could be used for mutation detection
in b -thalassemia carriers are oligonucleotide ligation assay
(Nickerson et al, 1990), restriction enzyme digestion (Pirastu et
al, 1989), denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis (Myer et al,
1985, Cai and Kan, 1990; Rosatelli et al, 1992), and primer
specific restriction map modification (Gasparini et al 1992).
Unknown mutations
For parents in whom the definition of the b -thalassemia
mutation is not made by one the procedures above described,
characterisation of b -thalassemia is obtained by denaturing
gradient gel electrophoresis, chemical mismatch cleavage analysis
(Orita et al, 1989) followed by direct sequencing (Sanger et al,
1977) on amplified single-strand DNA (Gyllesten and Erlich,
1988).
The most widely used among these methods is DGGE, a gel system
that separates DNA fragments as a function of melting temperature.
The b -globin gene is amplified by using five to seven pairs of
primers, one pair of each with an added GC clamp. Normal DNA and
DNA from homozygous b -thalassemia produce a single band with a
typical migration pattern, that depend on the globin gene sequences
contained in the amplified fragments (Rosatelli et al, 1992a). DNA
from heterozygous b -thalassemia results in the formation of four
bands, two of which are homoduplexes of the normal and mutated
allele, while the other two are heteroduplexes resulting from
annealing the strands of the normal allele to those of the mutated
allele (
Figure 3).
After localisation by DGGE, the mutation is defined by direct
sequencing of the DNA contained in the fragment. Direct b -globin
gene sequencing may be carried out manually or automatically.
Alternatively, the unknown mutation may be detected by a fully
automated integrated system for DNA fragment analysis (AHPLC).
If a mutation is not detected by DGGE analysis, we search for
the presence of small deletions by polyacrylamide gel
electrophoresis of the PCR-amplified products prepared for ARMS or
RDB analysis. This may lead to the detection of small deletions of
the b -globin gene, suspected from very high HbA 2
levels. Larger deletions of the cluster may be identified with
restriction fragment length polymorphism analysis by Southern blot
or PCR-based procedures.
In a very limited number of cases, direct sequencing from
position ?600 to 60 bp downstream from the b -globin gene failed to
detect a mutation causing b -thalassemia (Murru et al, 1990, 1992;
Rosatelli et al, 1992b). In these cases, the molecular defect may
reside either in the Locus Control Region at the b -globin gene
cluster, or in one of the genes outside the b -globin gene region
encoding for DNA-binding protein that regulates the function of the
b -globin gene (for a review see Orkin , 1990 and Townes and
Behriger 1990).
Prediction of a mild
phenotype
Homozygosity or compound heterozygosity for b-thalassaemia
usually results in the clinical phenotype of transfusion-dependent
thalassaemia major. However, a substantial proportion of these
homozygotes develop milder forms that range in severity from the
asymptomatic carrier state to thalassaemia major (thalassaemia
intermedia).
The main pathophysiological determinant of the severity of the
thalassaemia syndrome is the extent of a/nona chain imbalance. In
other words any factor capable of reducing this a/nona imbalance
may have an ameliorating effect on the clinical picture. The most
clinically relevant mechanism that consistently results in
thalassaemia intermedia is co-inheritance of homozygosity or
compound heterozygosity for a silent or mild b-thalassaemia allele,
namely a b-thalassaemia defect associated with a consistent
residual output of b chains from the affected b-globin locus
(Gonzales ? Redondo et al, 1989, Rosatelli et al, 1994, 1995). By
contrast, compound heterozygotes for a mild or silent and a severe
mutation may result in a spectrum of phenotypes including severe
and mild forms.
Other mechanisms capable of ameliorating the phenotype of
homozygous b-thalassaemia are the co-inheritance of a-thalassaemia
(Wainscoat et al, 1983; Galanello et al, 1989) or genetic
determinants capable of sustaining the continuous production of
g-chains in adult life, thereby reducing the extent of the a/non-a
chain unbalance (Rochette et al, 1994).
However, neither mechanism can be used to predict a mild
phenotype prospectively, because neither results in a consistent
effect. It is worth noting that thalassaemia intermedia may also
result from heterozygosity for hyper-unstable Hb or a compound
heterozygous state for typical heterozygous b-thalassaemia and the
triple a-globin arrangement.
Nevertheless, in many cases the determinantfor the mild
phenotype has not been defined so far.
a-Thalassaemias
Deletion a� or a+-thalassaemias are detected by PCR using two
primers flanking the deletion breakpoints that amplify a DNA
segment only in presence of the specific deletions (reviewed in
Kattamis et al, 1996). As a control, DNA from a normal chromosome
is simultaneously amplified using one of the primers flanking the
breakpoint and a primer homologous to a DNA region deleted by the
mutation. In addition, non-deletion a-thalassaemias are detected by
restriction enzyme analysis on selectively amplified a1-
and a2-globin genes or, when restriction is not
applicable, by dot blot analysis with allele-specific
oligonucleotide probes. Besides defining the molecular defect in
carriers of a-thalassaemia, a-globin gene analysis can also
discriminate between heterozygous a-thalassaemia and double
heterozygosity for d- and b-thalassaemia or gdb-thalassaemia.
Definition of the a-globin gene arrangement could also be useful to
predict the clinical phenotype of homozygous b-thalassaemia.
Sickle cell
anaemia
Sickle cell anaemia most commonly results from homozygosity for
the HbS mutation. Nevertheless, it may also be caused by compound
heterozygosity for the HbS mutation and HbC, b+, or b
�-thalassemia, or other rare haemoglobin variants such as HbO Arab.
Molecular diagnosis for carriers of these conditions may be carried
out with the same procedure described for b-thalassaemia, and
especially by dot blot analysis with allele-specific probes or
primer-specific amplification.
The severity of sickle cell anaemia may be modulated by a number
of co-inherited modifying genes, a-thalassaemia and HPHF being the
most noteworthy (Steinberg, 1996). The only determinant
consistently associated with a milder phenotype is presence of high
HbF resulting from the group of heterogeneous conditions discussed
previously under genetic counselling for couples at risk for
b-thalassaemia.
In order to predict the clinical phenotype appropriately, during
genetic counselling to couples at risk, these modifying factors
should be defined by appropriate procedures (see section on
b-thalassaemia).
Prenatal
diagnosis
Prenatal diagnosis of both a- and b-thalassaemia was
accomplished for the first time in the 1970s with globin chain
synthesis analysis of fetal blood obtained by fetoscopy or
placental aspiration (Kan et al, 1975). Molecular definition of the
thalassaemias, the development of procedures for their detection by
DNA analysis, and the introduction of chorionic villus sampling in
the last decade have dramatically improved prenatal detection of
these disorders. For a short period the diagnosis of thalassaemia
was obtained either indirectly by polymorphism analysis (Kan et al,
1980) or directly by oligonucleotide hybridisation on
electrophoretically separated DNA fragments (Pirastu et al, 1983).
Today thalassaemias are detected directly by the analysis of
amplified DNA from fetal trophoblast or amniotic fluid cells.
Fetal DNA
sampling
Fetal DNA for analysis can be obtained from amniocytes or from
chorionic villi. At present the most widely used procedure is
chorionic villi sampling, mainly because of the clear advantage of
being carried out during the first trimester of pregnancy,
generally at the 10th-12th week of gestation (Hogge et al, 1986;
Cao et al, 1987; Brambati et al, 1988). The risk of fetal mortality
associated with this method is of the order of 1%. Chorionic villi
may be obtained transcervically or transabdominally. We prefer the
transabdominal route for several reasons, mainly because it has a
low infection rate, a lower incidence of amniotic fluid leakage,
because it is a simple procedure, and also because it is largely
preferred by pregnant women.
Fetal DNA
analysis
Fetal DNA is analysed using the methods described earlier for
the detection of known mutations during carrier definition. To
limit the possibility of misdiagnosis, we analyse chorionic villous
DNA with two different procedures: i.e. RDB hybridisation and
primer-specific amplification (ARMS).
Misdiagnosis may occur for several reasons: failure to amplify
the target DNA fragment, mispaternity, maternal contamination, and
sample exchange. Misdiagnosis for failure of DNA amplification is
obviously limited by the double approach described above. To avoid
misdiagnosis resulting from mispaternity or maternal contamination,
we carry out DNA polymorphism analysis parallelly with mutation
analysis. In addition to this, the presence or effect of maternal
contamination could also be limited by careful dissection of the
maternal decidua from the fetal trophoblast under the inverted
microscope, and by the fact that a minimal amount (about 3 mg) of
chorionic villi are requested to reduce the chances of
co-amplifying the DNA from the maternal decidua.
The advent of DNA amplification has made it possible to analyse
the genotype of a single cell. This has paved the way for
pre-implantation or even pre-conceptional diagnosis (Monk and
Holding, 1990; Handyside et al, 1992).
Pre-implantation may be carried out by a biopsy of the blastula,
obtained by washing the uterine cavity after in vivo fertilisation,
or by analysis of a single blastomere from an eight-cell embryo
after in vitro fertilisation. Pre-conception diagnosis is based on
the analysis of the first polar body of unfertilised eggs, and may
lead to distinguish between unfertilised eggs that carry the
defective gene and those without the defect. By fertilising in
vitro only the eggs without the defect and replacing them in the
mother, a successful pregnancy with a normal fetus can be obtained.
Of course, the genotype of the fetus will be checked further by
chorionic villus biopsy.
Successful pregnancies following the transfer of human embryos
in which a single gene defect has been excluded, have been
reported.
Pre-implantation and pre-conception gamete diagnoses are very
useful for couples against pregnancy termination for ethical
reasons, and especially for those who have already had therapeutic
abortions due to genetic risks. At present, however, its use in
routine monitoring of pregnancies at risk is precluded by the
technical demand for these procedures, the difficulty organising
the service, and the high costs.
POPULATION SCREENING
AND COUNSELLING FOR HAEMOGLOBIN DISORDERS
Couples at risk for haemoglobin disorders may be identified
retrospectively, i.e. following the birth of an affected child, or
prospectively by analysing childless spouses. The benefit from
prospective identification is obviously greater, because it gives
parents the opportunity of planning a family without disease, and
it alleviates the health burden to society. Prospective
identification of couples at risk is carried out by population
screening. To date programmes aimed at prospective identification
and counselling of couples at risk for inherited
haemoglobinopathies have been carried out significantly only for
b-thalassaemia. These programmes are ongoing in several areas at
risk in the Mediterranean basin, such as Cyprus, Greece, several
regions of continental Italy, and Sardinia (Angastiniotis et al,
1995; Cao et al, 1996; Loukopoulos, 1996).
All these programmes are characterised by intensive education
and involvement of the population, screening of prospective couples
and non-directive counselling. They have been very successful,
because the population was well informed about thalassaemia and the
methodology for its prevention, and there were no consistent
adverse effects on those found to be carriers. Furthermore, in
populations in the Mediterranean area where screening and
counselling have been introduced, a marked decline has been
observed in the incidence of thalassaemia major, the homozygous
state of b-thalassaemia (Angastiniotis et al, 1995; Cao et al,
1996; Loukopoulos, 1996).
Very limited prospective screening for a-thalassaemia is carried
out in a few areas of South East Asia (Hong-Kong, Southern China,
Thailand, Taiwan), and for sickle cell anaemia in the Caribbean,
the United Kingdom and the USA.
FUTURE PROSPECTS
Technically, in carrier screening and prenatal diagnosis we can
realistically predict further simplification and full automation of
the procedures for the detection of the b-thalassaemia mutation.
Primer-specific amplification and reverse oligonucleotide
hybridisation, for instance, could easily become fully automated.
An oligonucleotide microchip assay has been proposed recently for
the large-scale detection of mutations in genetic diseases,
including b-thalassaemia. Given the alternative features of high
throughput, automation and modest cost, the DNA chip has the
potential to become a valuable method in future applications of
mutation detection in medicine (Yershov et al, 1996).
The foreseeable progressive reduction in the cost of DNA
analysis may lead to the use of mutation detection as a future
screening method, thus skipping all carrier detection steps based
on haematological analysis.
Simplification of pre-implantation and pre-conception gamete
diagnosis may lead to a more extensive use of the procedure in the
future, especially by couples against pregnancy termination.
However, the most relevant advance would be fetal diagnosis by
analysis of fetal cells in maternal circulation.
So far, many methods have been proposed for analysis, but none
has given reliable results (Bianchi et al, 1990; Ganshirt-Ahlert et
al, 1993).
Point mutations responsible for b-thalassaemia or sickle cell
anaemia have recently been identified successfully on fetal cells
with a procedure based on the density gradient separation of
mononuclear cells from maternal blood, the enrichment of fetal
cells by magnetically activated cell sorting using the
anti-transferrin receptor antibody, the identification of fetal
cells by immunostaining with anti-fetal or embryonic haemoglobin
antibodies, the isolation of nucleated red cells by
micro-dissection under light microscopy, and non-radioactive PCR
analysis (Cheung et al, 1996). The simplification and partial
automation of this procedure may lead to the introduction of
prenatal diagnosis by analysis of fetal cells in the maternal
circulation in clinical practice.
Nevertheless, the most important challenge for the future is the
organisation of similar genetic preventive programmes to those
ongoing in the Mediterranean area, in parts of the world where
b-thalassaemia is prevalent, namely the Middle East, the Indian
subcontinent, and the Far East. Nonetheless, the resources for
population education and the present state of technical development
seem to preclude the realisation of such a programme.
Acknowledgements
We thank Rita Loi for editorial assistance.
References
- Angastiniotis M, Modell B, Boulinzhenkov V (1995) Prevention
and control of haemoglobinopathies.Bulletin of the World Health
Organization73: 375-86.
- Bianchi DW, Flint Af, Pizzimenti MF et al (1990) Isolation of
fetal DNA from nucleated erythrocytes in maternal blood.Proceeding
of the National Academy of Sciences (USA)87: 3279-83
- Brambati B, Lanzani A, Oldrini A (1988) Transabdominal
chorionic villus sampling, clinical experience of 1159
cases.Prenatal Diagnosis8: 609-13.
- Cai SP, Kan YW (1990) Identification of the multiple b
-thalassemia mutations by denaturing gradient gel
electrophoresis.Journal of Clinical Investigation85: 550-3.
- Cao A, Rosatelli C, Galanello R: Control of b -thalassemia by
carrier screening, genetic counselling and prenatal diagnosis: the
Sardinian experience. In 1996 Variation of the human
genome. Wiley, Chichester (Ciba Foundation Symposium, 197)
137-55
- Cao A, Cossu P, Monni G, Rosatelli C (1987) Chorionic villus
sampling and acceptance rate of prenatal diagnosis.Prenatal
Diagnosis7: 531-3.
- Cao A, Galanello R, Rosatelli C (1998) Prenatal diagnosis and
screening of the haemoglobinopathies. Bailli�re's Clinical
Haematology. Sickle Cell Disease and
Thalassemia.vol.11No. 1, Bailli�re Tindall. 215-38.
- Cheung M-C, Goldberg JD, Kan YW (1996) Prenatal diagnosis of
sickle cell anemia and thalassemia by analysis of fetal cells in
maternal blood. Nature Genetics14: 264-8.
- Cotton RGH, Rodrigues NR, Campbell RD (1988) Reactivity of
cytosine and thymine in single-base-pair mismatches with
hydroxylamine and osmium tetroxide and its application to the study
of mutations.Proceeding of the National Academy of Sciences
(USA)85: 4397-401.
- Galanello R, Ruggeri R, Addis M, Paglietti E, Cao A (1981)
Hemoglobin A2 in iron deficiency b -thalassaemia
heterozygotes.Hemoglobin5: 613-8.
- Galanello R, Ruggeri R, Paglietti E et al (1983) A family with
segregating triplicated a -globin loci and b -thalassemia.Blood62:
1035-40.
- Galanello R, Paglietti ME, Addis M et al (1988) Pitfalls in
genetic counselling for b -thalassemia: an individual with 4
different thalassemia mutations.Clinical Genetics33: 151-5.
- Galanello R, Barella S, Ideo A et al (1994) Genotype of
subjects with borderline Hb A2: Implication for b -thalassemia
carrier screening. American Journal of Hematology46: 79-81.
- Galanello R, Barella S, Gasperini D et al (1995) Evaluation of
a new automatic HPLC analyzer for thalassemia and hemoglobin
variants screening.Journal of Automatic Chemistry17: 73-6.
- Ganshirt-Ahlert D, Borjesson-Stoll R, Burschyk M et al (1993)
Detection of fetal trisomies 21 and 18 from maternal blood using
triple gradient and magnetic cell sorting. American Journal of
Reproduction Immunology30: 194-201.
- Gasparini P, Bonizzato A, Dognini M and Pignatti PF (1992)
Restriction site generating-polymerase chain reaction (RG-PCR) for
the probeless detection of hidden genetic variation: application to
the study of some common cystic fibrosis mutations.Molecular and
Cellular Probes6: 1-7.
- Gonzales-Redondo JM, Stoming TA, Kutlar A, et al (1989) A C� T
substitution at nt ?101 in a conserved DNA sequence of the promoter
region of the b -globin gene is associated with "silent" b
-thalassemia.Blood73: 1705-11
- Gyllensten UB, Erlich HA (1988) Generation of single stranded
DNA by the polymerase chain reaction and its application to direct
sequencing of the HLA-DQ locus.Proceeding of the National Academy
of Sciences (USA)85: 7652-6.
- Handyside AM, Lesko JG, Tarin JJ et al (1992) Birth of a normal
girl after in vitro fertilization and preimplantation diagnostic
testing for cystic fibrosis.New England Journal of Medicine327:
905-9.
- Higgs DR, Aldridge BE, Lamb J et al (1982) The interaction of
alpha-thalassemia and homozygous sickle-cell disease.New England
Journal of Medicine306: 1441-6.
- Hogge WA, Schonberg SA, Golbus MS (1986) Chorionic villus
sampling: experience of the first 1000 cases.American Journal of
Obstetrics and Gynaecology154: 1249-52.
- Huisman THJ and Carver MFH (1998) The b - and d -thalassemia
repository (8th edn).Hemoglobin19: 213-36.
- Kan YW, Golbus MS, Klein P, Dozy AM (1975) Successful
application of prenatal diagnosis in a pregnancy at risk for
homozygous b -thalassemia.New England Journal of Medicine292:
1096-9.
- Kan YW, Lee KY, Furbetta M et al (1980) Polymorphism of DNA
sequence in the b -globin gene region: application to prenatal
diagnosis of b -thalassemia in Sardinia.New England Journal of
Medicine302: 185-8.
- Kattamis AC, Camaschella C, Sivera P et al (1996). Human a
-thalassemia syndromes: detection of nolecular defects.American
Journal of Hematology53: 81-91.
- Kulozik AE, Thein SL, Wainscoat JS et al (1987) Thalassemia
intermedia: interaction of the triple a -globin gene arrangement
and heterozygous b -thalassaemia.British Journal of Haematology66:
109-12.
- Loukopoulos D (1996) Current status of thalassemia and the
sickle cell syndromes in Greece.Seminars in Hematology33:76-86
- Melis MA, Pirastu M, Galanello R et al (1983) Phenotypic effect
of heterozygous a and b �-thalassaemia interaction.Blood62:
226-9.
- Monk M, Holding C (1990) Amplification of a b -haemoglobin
sequence in individual human oocytes and polar bodies.Lancet325:
985-8.
- Murru S, Loudianos G, Vaccargiu S et al (1990) A b -thalassemia
carrier with normal sequences within the b -globin
gene.[letter].Blood76: 64-5.
- Murru S, Loudianos G, Porcu S, et al, (1992) A b -thalassaemia
phenotype not linked to the b -globin cluster in an Italian
family.British Journal of Haematology81: 283-7.
- Myers RM, Fisher SG, Lerman LS , Maniatis T (1985) Nearly all
single base substitution in DNA fragments joined to a GC-clamp can
be detected by denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis.Nucleid
Acids Research13: 3131-5.
- Newton CR, Graham A, Hepteinstall LE et al (1989) Analysis of
any point mutation in DNA. The amplification refractory mutation
system (ARMS).Nucleic Acid Research17: 2503-16.
- Nickerson DA, Kaiser R, Loggin S et al (1990) Automated DNA
diagnostic using an Elisa-based oligonucleotide ligation
Assay.Proceeding of the National Academy of Sciences (USA)87:
8923-7.
- Orita M, Iwahana H, Kanazawa H et al (1989) Detection of
polymorphisms of human DNA by gel electrophoresis as single-strand
conformation polymorphism.Proceedings of the National Academy of
Science (USA)86: 2766-70.
- Orkin SE (1990) Globin gene regulation and switching: circa
1990.Cell63: 665-72.
- Pirastu M, Kan YW, Cao A et al (1983) Prenatal diagnosis of b
-thalassemia. Detection of a single nucleotide mutation in DNA.New
England Journal of Medicine309: 284-7.
- Pirastu M, Ristaldi MS, and Cao A (1989) Prenatal diagnosis of
b -thalassemia based on restriction endonuclease analysis of
amplified fetal DNA. Journal of Medical Genetics26: 363-7.
- Rochette J, Craig JE, Thein SL (1994) Fetal hemoglobin levels
in adults.BloodReviews8: 213-224.
- Rosatelli C, Falchi AM, Scalas MT et al (1984) Hemat
- ological phenotype of the double heterozygous state for a and b
thalassemia.Hemoglobin8: 25-35.
- Rosatelli MC, Dozy A, Faa V et al (1992a) Molecular
characterization of b -thalassemia in the Sardinian
population.Americal Journal of Human Genetics50: 422-6.
- Rosatelli C, Tuveri T, Scalas MT et al. (1992b) Molecular
screening and fetal diagnosis of b -thalassemia in the Italian
population.Human Genetics83:590-2.
- Rosatelli MC, Pischedda A., Meloni A., Saba L., Pomo A., Travi
M., Fattore S., Cao A. (1994) Homozygous b -thalassemia resulting
in the b -thalassemia carrer state phenotype.British Journal of
Haematology, 88: 562-565.
- Rosatelli MC, Faa V, Meloni A, Fiorenza F, Galanello R,
Gasperini D, Amendola G, Cao A, (1995) A promoter mutation, C � T
position ? 92, leading to silent b -thalassemia.British Journal of
Haematology, 90: 483-485.
- Saiki RK, Walsh PS, Levenson CH, Erlich HA (1989) Genetic
analysis of amplified DNA with immobilized sequence-specific
oligonucleotide probes.Proceedings of the National Academy of
Sciences (USA)86: 6230-4.
- Sanger F, Micklen S, Coulson AR (1977) DNA sequencing with
chain terminating inhibitors.Proceedings of the National Academy of
Sciences (USA)74: 5463-7.
- Steinberg MG (1996) Modulation of the phenotypic diversity of
sickle cell anemia.Hemoglobin20: 1-19.
- Thein SL, Sl-Hakim I and Hoffbrand AB (1984) Thalassaemia
intermedia: a new molecular basis.British Journal of Haematology56:
333-7.
- Townes TM, Behringer RR ( 1990) Human globin locus activation
region (LAR): role in temporal control.Trends in Genetics6:
219-23.
- Weatherall SJ, Clegg JB (1981) The Thalassaemia
Syndromes. 3rd edn. Blackwell Scientific Publication,
Oxford.
- WHO Scientific Group (1996) Control of hereditary diseases..WHO
Technical Report Series 865.
- Wainscoat JS, Kanavakis E. Wood WG et al (1983) Thalassemia
intermedia interaction of a and b thalassemia.British Journal of
Haematology53: 411- 416
- Yershov G, Barsky V, Belgovskiy A, et al. (1996) DNA analysis
and diagnostics on oligonucleotide microchips. Proceedings of the
National Academy of Sciences (USA)93: 4913-8.
Figures
Figure
1: flow chart for b -thalassaemia carrier screening
Figure 2: Screening for the most common b -thalassaemia
mutations by reverse dot blot analysis.
Top: the whole b -globin gene is enzymatically amplified using
primer A and B.
Bottom: A b -thalassaemia heterozygote for b IVS I-110
mutation.
W = wild type oligonucleotide hybridization
M = mutated oligonucleotide hybridization
Figure 3: Denaturating gradient (42% � 72%) gel electrophoresis
for detecting heterozygotes for b -thalassemia. The b -globin
genotype of each subject is indicated on top.
|